While Restoring the Oldest Cemetery in Jersey City, Pastor Unearths Secret About His Past

Old Bergen Church Jersey City 0322
The cemetery across the street from the Old Bergen Church is the oldest in Jersey City and dates back to the 17th century. Photo by Darren Tobia/Jersey Digs.

When Reverend Jon Brown became pastor of the Old Bergen Church in Jersey City, he was drawn to the parish’s historic but rundown graveyard. Tombstones with barely legible inscriptions in the state’s oldest European burial ground told a story of the earliest days of a Dutch settlement and were some of the last vestiges of the founding families.

“I saw names like Sip, Vroom, Van Vorst, and Newkirk, all street names in our city,” said Brown, who lived in Louisville, Kentucky, prior to moving to Journal Square, Jersey City. “The cemetery is a treasure of history. But there was work to be done.”

After centuries of neglect, long enough for a tree to swallow up one of the headstones in its trunk, Brown vowed to restore the cemetery. Historians already knew that the number of headstones visible in the two-acre gated yard on Bergen Avenue didn’t accurately depict the number of people who slept beneath the soil. The identities of many were a mystery because the church records from the 17th century were handwritten in Dutch.

Old Bergen Church Jersey City 0281
Some headstones have held up over the last two centuries, but others have been damaged beyond repair by plant growth and water. Photo by Darren Tobia/Jersey Digs.

The first order of business was to use ground-penetrating radar that confirmed more than 1,200 parishioners were buried there, whereas the records only indicated 800. Then, once the Holland Historical Society translated the old parchments into English, a long-held secret was revealed.

“Without even knowing it, I found out my own ancestor was buried there in that cemetery,” said Brown, who had always assumed his paternal descendants lived on Long Island or in Brooklyn, where most of his family was born. “And I thought I had no direct connection to Jersey City or this church.”

Not long after sailing across the Atlantic and giving birth to a daughter, the wife of Jan Van Wicklen — who is unnamed in the records — died in 1668. She was the second person ever buried there. The pastor’s discovery of a long-lost ancestor is a reminder that many of the stories we inherit about our families are stretched and pulled over generations.

Old Bergen Church Jersey City 0327
Headstones made of limestone, like the one pictured in the middle, often don’t hold up as well as those made of sandstone. Photo by Darren Tobia/Jersey Digs.

“Cemeteries are quite often the only way to find information about where someone was born or even where someone died,” said Michael Leclerc, Managing Editor of Association of Professional Genealogists Quarterly. “Well into the 19th century, we don’t have birth records and death records.”

The suburbanization of the United States in the mid-20th-century left many small, urban church cemeteries abandoned. Fortunately, there has been a resurgence of interest in preserving cemeteries. The $240,000 restoration at Old Bergen Church — funded by two Hudson County open-air grants, as well as private donations — has given the headstones and obelisks a long-overdue spit-shine. When the cemetery reopens to visitors on Bergen Square Day, Oct. 23, pebbled walking paths will allow visitors to wend through these artifacts with a self-guided tour.

“The stones themselves — with the grave art and inscriptions — tell you a lot about the culture of these people in general as well as the specific families,”  Leclerc said. ”These cemeteries tell the story of the people who once lived here.”


Have something to add to this story? Email [email protected].

Click here to sign up for Jersey Digs' free emails and news alerts. Stay up-to-date by following Jersey Digs on Twitter and Instagram, and liking us on Facebook.

No posts to display