Hoboken’s Tutta Pesca Opening Restaurant and Event Space on First Street

557 First Street Hoboken
Plans have been submitted to revamp the former Northern Soul space at 557 First Street in Hoboken. Image by Chris Fry/Jersey Digs.

A seafood market and Italian eatery that has been working out of a narrow building for several years will be moving to a bigger facility set to include two floors of space plus a rear patio area.

As the COVID-19 pandemic struck New Jersey, Tutta Pesca at 155 Third Street shuttered both their market and restaurant space in a move somewhat surprising to locals. The business opened in 2016 and quickly became a huge success, but the restaurant area had just 32 seats and lines outside the building became commonplace due to the limitations.

The Third Street building that housed Tutta Pesca has been listed for sale since the closing, but ownership behind the endeavor has been planning their move to a larger space for some time. Last May, an entity called 557 First Street LLC purchased a building at that same address and ownership of that company can be traced to Tutta Pesca owner Michael Caracappa.

557 First Street Hoboken Revamp Elevation
Designed by Nastasi Architects, the business envisions setting up shop on the first two floors of the building and wishes to renovate a rear patio at the property. Image courtesy of Nastasi Architects.

Plans have officially been submitted to revamp the former home of Northern Soul, which looks to expand the current three-story building vertically by one floor. Designed by Nastasi Architects, the business envisions setting up shop on the first two floors of the building and wishes to renovate a rear patio at the property.

Tutta Pesca Seafood Market Hoboken
Plans indicate that the seafood market component could return in the new digs. Image via Facebook.

The first floor of the restaurant would feature mostly table service and plans show a 625-square foot service and retail area near the front, perhaps an indicator that the seafood market component could return in the new digs. The eatery’s second story would have a separate event space in the front and an additional general dining area in the back, where the restaurant’s rear patio would be accessed.

The plans indicate that the restaurant would be called Tutta Pasta, a name that has some local history. A restaurant on Washington Street operated under the moniker for many years and was a frequent hangout of Oscar-nominated actor Danny Aiello, who owned a comedy club above the eatery. The restaurant closed in 2013 and has since been replaced by a realtor office.

Tutta Pesca Hoboken Zuppa Di Pesca
Zuppa Di Pesca. Image via Facebook.

The remainder of the plans at 557 First Street call for two apartments above the restaurant. The third-floor space would feature three bedrooms and the fourth-floor unit, which would be built as an addition, would sport two bedrooms plus a roof deck. An underground water detention system designed to mitigate flooding in the neighborhood is included in the plans.

Tutta Pesca’s new facility would allow the business to seat about 92 diners in over 3,000-square feet not counting the back patio and will be requesting several variances from current zoning to move forward. They include deviations for floor to ceiling height, rear yard depth, use of non-masonry materials on the exterior, and off-street parking requirements.

An inquiry placed to ownership behind Tutta Pesca regarding the plans has not yet been returned. Some clarity could emerge later this month, as Hoboken’s planning board is scheduled to hear the restaurant’s application during their Subdivision and Site Plan meeting on July 14.



Have something to add to this story? Email [email protected].

Click here to sign up for Jersey Digs' free emails and news alerts. Stay up-to-date by following Jersey Digs on Twitter and Instagram, and liking us on Facebook.

No posts to display


  1. God, can you imagine living above a smelly seafood restaurant in a cramped city like Hoboken? Who by the way does not have any allys so all the garbage has to go to the curb in front of your apartment?

    Also the max exodus from thr immediate nyc area is gonna ruin all these new biz investments.

  2. Whatever smelly experience you have had in your life, I can tell from your comment you have never been to high end quality seafood restaurant or in its neighborhood. Do you even live in Hoboken? I highly recommend you to visit Tutta Pesca when they reopen because the food is wonderful, people are kind and seafood market was superb. Glad to see them stay in our town!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here