Historic Bank at Five Corners in Montclair to be Redeveloped

Historic Bank 475 Bloomfield Avenue Montclair 2
The three-story limestone bank, built-in 1914, was designed by York & Sawyer. Photo by Darren Tobia/Jersey Digs.

The former home of American National Bank in Montclair is being converted into a mixed-use commercial space. Vacant for the past five years, the three-story limestone building at 475 Bloomfield Avenue is being redeveloped by a company named SAF 475 Bloomfield, LLC, an affiliate of Saxum Real Estate. Their application was recently approved by the zoning board of adjustment for two setback variances, necessary to construct a rear exit to comply with the local building code.

“It’s a challenging building, these big, old bank buildings with big vaulted entries and double-height ceilings and ornate detail,” said David Genova, founding principal at Greenwood Development, which partnered with Saxum on the project.

Historic Bank 475 Bloomfield Avenue Montclair 3
Converting century-old bank buildings into mixed-use commercial space is a trend in real estate. Photo by Darren Tobia/Jersey Digs.

The 1914 building, located at the Five Corners in the Bloomfield Avenue Historic District, was designed by Manhattan-based firm York & Sawyer, famous for their early 20th-century bank buildings, such as the Federal Reserve Bank, Central Savings Bank, and the Brooklyn Trust Company Building.

Historic Bank 475 Bloomfield Avenue Montclair
Greenwood Development plans to preserve the original plasterwork and skylight in the building. Photo by Darren Tobia/Jersey Digs.

The first floor, Genova said, will eventually house a retailer and offices will be on the second and third floor. Although the developers considered other means of egress that wouldn’t have required a variance, constructing this new rear exit was the “least disruptive to the architecture,” Genova said, which includes the original plasterwork and a skylight.

The conversion of the landmark bank into retail is following a trend that includes the former Bank of Montclair building, built-in 1923, and the Montclair National Bank, built-in 1926, both owned by the Bravitas Group. Modern-day banking operations are ill-suited for these grandiose structures from the past.

The developers of 475 Bloomfield Avenue originally considered overhauling the interior to have more traditional floor plans, but decided on leaving the building with its mezzanines and dramatic skylight intact, Genova said.

“In the end, we felt that that didn’t do service to the beauty of the entryway,” Genova said. “We decided to focus on a retailer who would take that space in its glory.”


Have something to add to this story? Email [email protected].

Click here to sign up for Jersey Digs' free emails and news alerts. Stay up-to-date by following Jersey Digs on Twitter and Instagram, and liking us on Facebook.

No posts to display